Data-Driven Recruiting 101: How To Improve Your Hiring Process

Data-driven recruitment involves making objective hiring decisions by leveraging various data sources beyond traditional methods such as resume screening, interviewing, and job offers.

Recruitment teams employing a data-driven approach utilize a diverse set of recruiting metrics to assess the success of the recruitment process, using the insights gained to enhance its overall effectiveness.

Moreover, the collection and analysis of data in the recruitment process serve to eliminate guesswork and biases, ensuring the selection of the most suitable candidate for the role.

Key sources of data for data-driven recruitment include the recruitment technology integrated into your HR tech stack, such as your Applicant Tracking System (ATS) or candidate assessment solutions. Additionally, data can be derived from interview scores, Google Analytics, social media analytics, and other relevant sources.

Utilizing data in your hiring process not only enhances the quality of your hires but also provides several benefits, including:

Budget Allocation: Efficiently allocate your budget by tracking the source of hire. Identify which recruiting channels yield the most qualified candidates, allowing you to optimize your budget allocation accordingly.

Productivity and Efficiency: Boost productivity and efficiency by monitoring the communication between your hiring team and candidates. Analyze email exchanges to identify specific stages where you can streamline the hiring process and reduce time-to-hire.

Identifying Hiring Issues: Uncover potential hiring issues by reviewing application form conversion rates. Assess whether adjustments to questions or page redesigns are needed. Similarly, analyze candidate demographics to ensure fairness and identify any unintentional discrimination against protected groups.

Benchmarking and Forecasting: Use recruiting yield ratios to benchmark and forecast your hiring. Understand how many applicants are typically needed to make one hire. If applications are insufficient, consider sourcing or re-advertising the role.

Objective and Legally Defensible Decisions: Achieve more objective and legally defensible hiring decisions by selecting candidates based on assessment scores and structured interview results. This method provides a solid foundation for justifying your hiring choices.

Advocating for Process Improvements: Support the case for recruiting process improvements with data. For instance, if advocating for a referral program, present data demonstrating its effectiveness to strengthen your argument and justify the need for investment.

Incorporating data-driven practices into your hiring strategy empowers you to make informed decisions, optimize resources, and continually improve your recruitment processes.

Utilizing data in various aspects of the recruitment process facilitates data-driven decision-making. Let's explore some instances:

Sourcing:

• Assessing the origin of job applications is a pivotal recruitment Key Performance Indicator (KPI) and an exemplary use of data for decision-making.
• This approach enables the evaluation of the effectiveness of diverse channels such as job boards, advertisements, agencies, social media, and the company's career page, thereby allowing the calculation of the cost per hire.
• Allocating more resources to sources that yield high-quality candidates becomes apparent through data analysis. For instance, adjusting budgets towards niche job boards if they consistently generate more qualified candidates compared to platforms like Google or Facebook ads.

Selection Process:

• The selection process involves recruiters choosing individuals best suited for specific positions from a pool of applicants.
• Data collection during this process encompasses resume screening, skills assessment through tests, and job interviews, all contributing to informed decision-making based on verifiable historical data, test scores, and interview evaluations.

Candidate Experience:

• Candidate experience refers to an applicant's overall perception of the employer's hiring and onboarding process.
• Measurement of candidate experience involves the use of the Net Promoter Score through surveys, aiding in the identification of areas for improvement.
• Evaluating candidate job satisfaction also provides insights, with a high satisfaction score indicating alignment between the advertised role and the actual responsibilities.

Recruitment Planning:

• Extracting insights from recruitment data assists in addressing common challenges. For example:
• To reduce expenses, focus on cost-related KPIs such as cost per hire, job advertising performance, or application numbers per source.
• To expedite the recruitment process, concentrate on metrics like time to fill, time to hire, and time to productivity.
• For acquiring highly-skilled employees, emphasize quality-related metrics such as source of hire, candidates per hire, new hire turnover, and new hire retention rate.

Get started for free

Transform your tech hiring process and unlock the true potential of your organization.

Book a meeting Sign up now

Adopting a data-driven approach in recruiting offers numerous compelling reasons:

Speeding up the Hiring Process:

• By collecting data, you can identify bottlenecks in your recruitment process and address or automate them.
• Analyzing details like applicant drop-off rates, average time to hire, and the effectiveness of various recruitment methods allows for informed decision-making.
• For instance, simplifying the application process for early stages or automating interview scheduling can enhance efficiency.

Reducing Hiring Costs:

• Data-driven recruiting minimizes time to hire, optimizing recruitment budgets.
• Evaluating the necessity of recruitment technology ensures resources are allocated efficiently, eliminating unnecessary expenses.

Mitigating Hiring Bias and Enhancing Objectivity:

• A data-driven strategy facilitates objective candidate selection, fostering a legally defensible and diverse recruitment process.
• Pre-employment assessments and work sample tests based on objective data help remove biases, ensuring fair treatment irrespective of demographics.

Improving Candidate Experience:

• Data-driven recruitment streamlines and expedites the candidate experience, preventing potential candidates from abandoning applications due to lengthy processes.
• Seeking candidate feedback at multiple stages allows continuous improvement, making the process faster, smoother, and fairer.

Being Proactive Instead of Reactive:

• Data enables proactive planning by forecasting hiring needs based on turnover rates, business expansions, and internal mobility.
• Forecasting hiring time helps set realistic expectations for new employees and ensures the availability of a recruitment budget when urgent hiring needs arise.

Boosting Quality of Hire:

• Data-driven approaches help select highly qualified candidates using work sample test scores and general mental ability assessments.
• Analyzing data on top performers, turnover rates, and productivity levels from various hiring sources allows optimization for quality recruitment.

Setting up the Recruiting Team for Success:

• A data-driven recruitment model establishes a repeatable procedure, instilling confidence in recruiters and hiring managers.
• Increased confidence and operational efficiency lead to lower costs and higher productivity, adding significant value to the organization.

In essence, a data-driven recruitment strategy not only leverages the latest HR technology but also enhances the entire hiring process, making it more efficient, fair, and effective.

Now that you're familiar with the advantages of data-driven recruitment, let's explore some effective strategies applicable to your organization:

Opt for pertinent metrics and pinpoint data origins

Navigating through the myriad data points collected by your recruitment software can be overwhelming. To avoid this, identify the metrics most beneficial for enhancing your recruitment process. Align these metrics with your overall business objectives, drawing inspiration from the recruitment planning section of this blog for ideas.

Once you've identified key metrics, determine the sources of your data. This could include your Applicant Tracking System (ATS), Google Analytics (for source tracking), candidate survey feedback, budget data, hiring manager satisfaction, and more.

Construct a recruitment dashboard

A recruitment dashboard serves as a visual aid to interpret data, identify trends, and swiftly address issues. It displays information related to applicants, hires, campaigns, and budgets.

Investing in a recruitment dashboard facilitates the quick identification of problems and opportunities. Focus on the most critical Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that align with your targets.

Define actionable steps

Leveraging data in recruitment goes beyond mere tracking; it involves taking action based on insights gained.

For instance, if you observe an increase in low-quality candidates, investigate their source (e.g., a specific job board) and halt promotions there. Alternatively, if you notice a rise in applications from your careers page, consider investing in Search Engine Optimization (SEO) services to enhance your website's visibility on search engine results pages.

Acknowledge data limitations

Recognize that data is not infallible. A Harvard Business School survey revealed that 88% of executives are aware that HR tools may reject qualified candidates. This rejection often results from overly strict job descriptions and algorithms that screen resumes for an exhaustive list of required skills.

Factors such as work gaps in resumes for over six months can also lead to rejections, which may be due to legitimate life obligations like military deployments, pregnancy complications, caregiving responsibilities, or illness.

When utilizing data, understand that it provides a partial narrative. Delve deeper into the 'why' behind the data to comprehend the full picture. As a recruiter, rely on your interpretation of findings, drawing on your knowledge and experience to make informed recruitment decisions.

Compare pre- and post-implementation states and iterate

The value of data is maximized when you compare the state before and after implementing changes.

Evaluate whether your plan is yielding the desired results and, if not, identify opportunities for improvement. Analyzing data allows you to discern successful and unsuccessful hiring strategies, informing enhancements for future recruitment efforts.

Get started for free

Transform your tech hiring process and unlock the true potential of your organization.

Book a meeting Sign up now

Effectively implementing data-driven recruitment goes beyond the simple act of data collection. It necessitates a shift in mindset and a commitment to adopting new approaches to fully capitalize on the advantages of data-driven recruiting. A valuable starting point is conducting an audit of the data already amassed through your HR technology and considering how this information can be utilized to enhance your recruitment processes.